8 May 2013

A Blair-esque departure for Sir Alex – with Europe still nagging?

A decade ago Tony Blair and Alex Ferguson both made the same mistake.

They both announced they’d be retiring in a year or two, and as a result they quickly lost their authority.  In Ferguson’s case he told the world he’d be retiring at the end of the 2001-02 season.

Pre News refresh player

//

Then, in early 2002, the day before Manchester United were due to announce that Sven Goran Eriksson would be their new manager, Ferguson changed his mind.  He couldn’t stomach the idea of being without football, or not knowing what to do all day.  And he couldn’t stand the idea of Eriksson being his successor.

Just as well that he did.  For United have won almost as many trophies since 2002 as they did under Ferguson before then.

And Ferguson learnt the lesson.  When you announce your retirement, do so suddenly and unexpectedly, at a moment of your choosing.  And quit on a high, with the crowds wanting more.   That’s what he did today.

Manchester United are certainly on a high right now, having this season easily regained the league title from their rivals Manchester City.  And by a lovely statistical quirk, Fergie’s last match, against West Bromwich Albion on 19 May, will be his 1500th for the club.

I’ve seen about two-thirds of those games, home and away, including the very first, a dismal 2-0 defeat at Oxford United’s old Manor Ground in November 1986.  I was there for the treble in Barcelona in 1999, and Moscow in 2008, and saw us lift two other doubles.

If you’d have told me that afternoon in Oxford that Ferguson would bring back the title to Old Trafford (after a 19-year drought at that point), I’d have been delighted, though it took another seven years before the first one arrived (making a 26-year gap).

If you’d have told me in 1986 that Ferguson would win 13 titles in 27 years, I’ve have said you were mad, and so would everyone else.  And there are five FA Cups, and four League Cups, and the fact we’ve not been out of the top three in the League since 1991.

Farewell Fergie – Sir Alex Ferguson in pictures

And yet there’s a small blemish to that record, one which rankles with Sir Alex, and partly, in my view, explained why he kept going into his 70s.

United have not enjoyed the same success in Europe one would expect from a club which has been so dominant in English football.  And Manchester United more than anyone are a club built on their European pedigree.

We were the first side to play in the European Cup – against the wishes of the English football authorities – and in 1958 eight of the Busby Babes died in that quest.  Europe became an obsession for United’s then manager Matt Busby, finally fulfilled in 1968.  And yet during Liverpool’s great run of success in the 70s and 80s, they picked up four European Cups (plus another one later), United in contrast managed just two European Cups – the famous victory over Bayern  in 1999 and defeating Chelsea on penalties in Moscow in 2008 – but neither was totally convincing.  We were runners-up twice, resoundingly beaten by Barcelona in 2009 and 2011.

Ferguson may have far more league titles than any other manager, and more FA Cups, and a tremendous record with Aberdeen, but his lack of success in Europe is the blemish.

United have a record breaking run of 17 years in the European Cup (now, stupidly, called the Champions League), but over the years we’ve seen endless disappointments against lesser sides such as Monaco, Basle, Benfica and Bayer Leverkusen.  It’s an astonishing poor record given that United are one of the two wealthiest and best-supported clubs in the world.

Perhaps Sir Alex Ferguson concluded that if he carried on at Old Trafford he might pick up more domestic titles, but that further European success might prove as elusive as before.  The competition from Europe is probably stronger than ever before, not just from Barcelona and Real Madrid, but now from Germany, with the extraordinary and sudden emergence of Bayern Munich and Borussia Dortmund, who together beat the two Spanish sides so decisively in the recent semi-finals.  So it will now be an all-German final at Wembley at the end of May.

Sir Alex will no doubt be there, admiring two new great teams, yet troubled by the slight nagging feeling that his Manchester United never quite conquered Europe.

The greatest manager in the British game, undoubtedly.  But…

Michael Crick is author of The Boss: The Many Sides of Alex Ferguson. Follow @MichaelLCrick on Twitter

8 reader comments

  1. Jason Smyth says:

    Hi

    Would you not agree that he is hugely responsible for disgusting behaviour becoming acceptable and almost the norm? The fact that he banned BBC for years – when the licence fee payer paying some of his wages? The way he used verbal assaults and intimidation against referees.

    etc.

    I think he leaves a legacy like Thatcher did – pretty grim.

    J

  2. Ryan McDermott says:

    The sudden emergence of Bayern Munich? They have been more successful in Europe than Manchester United have; they have reached three out of four finals in the last four years. They have played at least one European final in every decade since the 1960s. What is this sudden emergence of which you speak?

  3. Simon says:

    There is the argument that Europe is much harder to win now than it was in the 70s 80s as the overall quality of opposition is higher. No other manager has won the CL more than twice in he same period as Ferguson.
    The ban on Enlish teams competeing in Europe seriously reduced their competitiveness and it took time to restore this. He was also very unlucky to come up against arguably the greatest ever club team in Pep’s Barca team.

  4. Matthew Tyzack says:

    “I’ve seen about two-thirds of those games, home and away, including the very first, a dismal 2-0 defeat at Oxford United’s old Manor Ground in November 2006” … should be November 1986.

  5. ian carty says:

    the boss by michael crick is excellent, the best biography of fergie, hope it comes to the amazon kindle soon

  6. Steven says:

    Michael Crick – talks about ‘we’ and ‘us’ but can’t help having a dig. That article says more about you than it does about SAF. Sometimes praise is due without highlighting the odd blemish but as a journo, you can’t see that. How many people will comment when Crick retires? QED.

  7. Jon Wood says:

    Any idea how the bookies got wind of today’s announcement the evening before?

  8. Robert Taggart says:

    One-up for Liverpool / Paisley !
    Come on you Birdies !!

Comments are closed.