18 Apr 2014

The power of parody in eastern Ukraine

The tired looking young men in t-shirts and combat fatigues manning the barricades in Slovyansk say they are not going anywhere.

Yesterday the agreement thrashed out in Geneva between the EU, the US, Russia and Ukraine said that all unauthorised roadblocks and occupied municipal buildings should be cleared.

But they’re not obeying those orders in eastern Ukraine.

Pre News refresh player – this is the default player for the C4 news site – please do not delete. Ziad


“The government in Kiev seized buildings, that’s how they got to power so we will leave when they do,” said a round faced man in a black jacket.

What those occupying government building in eastern Ukraine are doing is an echo of the Maidan, the 24-hour encampment in central Kiev that brought down the government of Viktor Yanukovych back in February.

Western governments were enthusiastic about that uprising. Senator John McCain took a tour of those barricades so did William Hague. Many here in eastern Ukraine believe European and US governments didn’t just support the revolution in Kiev, but they fomented it.

The Russian government has been studying the language and tactics used by the west. These days, instead of railing against the “colour revolution” of the early 2000s that brought western-leaning governments to power in former Soviet states, it is simply mimicking their tactics.

That’s why those manning the barricades here won’t abandon them until the remains of the encampment in Maidan, which has turned into a memorial for the “heavenly hundred” killed back in February, has been dismantled.

What people in Kiev call a revolution those here call a coup.

President Putin has also borrowed the language of “humanitarian intervention” invoked by western powers after the failure to stop genocide in Rwanda 20 years ago. That catastrophe, in which 800,000 were killed, led to the doctrine of Responsibility To Protect or R2P which authorises countries to intervene in sovereign states if civilians face slaughter or starvation.

Mr Putin says the people of Crimea were facing a humanitarian disaster back in March. Russian media said hundreds of thousands were fleeing persecution. (They weren’t – I saw no such exodus.)

Russian politicians said that Crimeans who spoke the Russian language were under threat. That, says the Russian government, meant they had no choice but to intervene. It was their Responsibility to Protect.

The same language is being used in eastern Ukraine. The government in Kiev says it has sent soldiers to restore law and order, but Russia says the troops are threatening to kill people here. Reluctantly, and under great provocation, the Russians say they may be forced to intervene again.

It is said history repeats itself – first as tragedy then as farce. But in eastern Ukraine it seems it repeats itself not as farce but as parody.

Follow Lindsey Hilsum on Twitter: @lindseyhilsum

Tweets by @lindseyhilsum

3 reader comments

  1. Philip Edwards says:

    Frankly, I have hugely enjoyed the images of you and your fellow propaganda-manufacturing liars with egg all over your hypocritical faces. You have had your own methods turned on you by the rather simple method of holding up a mirror in your faces.

    As somebody once said, you don’t like it up you.

    The real sufferers in all this are of course the Ukrainian people who have to endure an unelected violent junta in Kiev. You remember them, they’re the ones people like you egged on with lies and distortions, the ones put in place by Western “intelligence” services. You even went first to Lviv (Lvov), home of Ukrainian neoNazis and scene of a massacre of Jews and partisans in the Second World War.

    What a disgusting, lying disgrace you are to British journalism, every bit as bad as the Murdoch crew. If the situation turns into civil war it will be people like you who did their tiny-minded best to help provoke it.

    People like you and Hague (whatever DID happen to the “Atlantic Bridge”?) make me ashamed of my country.

  2. Alan says:

    Interestingly as the public theatre in Geneva was being performed, US and Polish defence were discussing the deployment of US troops on Polish soil. The hypocrisy of so called leaders is astounding. The dropping of the Rwandan tragedy in the article is rather tasteless given the UN, US, EU complicity with media distortion. We have zero faith that anything the current self appointed leaders do will help the people of the Ukraine.

  3. Glyn Allott says:

    Lindsey, why do you keep peddling this nonsense to a British public which simply doesn’t buy it. Tell the truth for once, that the troika of USA/NATO/EU is using Ukraine as a pawn in their masterplan towards European and global hegemony. Is it an wonder that Russia is resisting their moves?

Comments are closed.