Published on 18 Nov 2013

Dreaming of Europe, Africa’s migrants risk disease, rape and death

They abandoned two of their group to die in the desert.

“One man had malaria and the other had hurt his leg,” explained Hanna. “What could we do? We just carried on. The driver said either you get back in the vehicle or I leave you here too. We cried but we had no choice.”

Pre News refresh player – this is the default player for the C4 news site – please do not delete. Ziad


She didn’t know their names. They had only just met, drawn together by chance after paying a smuggler to take them across the Sahara. Her journey began in Eritrea. Theirs ended somewhere in Niger, anonymous whitening bones vanishing into the vast desert. Hanna mourned them but believed in her own good fortune. She had no idea of the horror that awaited her in Libya and beyond.

Tyre tracks scour the sandy outskirts of the southern Libyan city of Sebha, evidence of the Hilux pickups driven by smugglers who every night bring cigarettes, drugs, alcohol and people. “They used to bring weapons too,” said a young man whose family land was nearby. He laughed. “Now there are so many weapons in Libya, there’s no point.”

Migrants from sub-Saharan Africa have passed through Libya for years, but since the revolution two years ago border patrols have dwindled to almost nothing. Gaddafi encouraged Africans to come to work as cleaners, manual labourers and guards in Libya and persecuted those who tried to travel onto Europe. The current government, unable to control what happens inside the country, let alone the borders, has no clear policy, and the migrants are making the journey in ever larger numbers.

In an abandoned factory Sebha’s immigration authority had gathered 150 men for deportation. They sat on the concrete floor, skinny bodies crammed together, faces upturned, hoping that visitors might bring deliverance. It was a scene from a 19th century slaving boat, only these men had traveled willingly and in hope.

Some said they wanted to stay and work in Libya, to send money home to their families in Ghana, Gambia, Sudan or Chad, but others had a more ambitious goal: Europe.

Ousmane Manka, a tall, slim boy in a dirty red T-shirt, said he was 14. His parents had died back home in the village in Senegal; he hadn’t finished school but he hoped he could complete his education in Europe. He was vague about how he might get there but hoped, if he earned enough money as a labourer in Libya, he could earn enough to pay the smugglers who organise the boat trip across the Mediterranean. I asked what he would do now he was being deported back home.

“I shall try again,” he said.

Five hundred miles away in Tripoli, Hanna and her friends gathered in a basement. Like Ousmane, they had dreamed of Europe. “In Eritrea we have no freedom and we are poor,” said Hanna’s friend, Aster. She had clear, aquiline features, her abundant hair covered in a pale brown patterned scarf. Although they were Christians, they covered their heads like Muslims to remain inconspicuous. After her husband died she had gone to Sudan and across the desert to Libya, where she found work as a housemaid. Her Libyan employers hadn’t paid her, but she met Hanna, whose husband earned enough working as a labourer to pay the smugglers US $1,500 each to get all three of them across the Mediterranean to Lampedusa.

They set off around midnight one night in early August. Soon the boat was taking in water and the Somali man the smugglers had taught to steer the craft was losing control. The women wept; everyone prayed. The smugglers had given them a satellite phone and the number of the Italian coastguard – now they had no choice but to make the call. After seven hours the Italians arrived and transferred them onto a Turkish vessel that took them back to Tripoli. They were handed over to the Libyan authorities who put them in detention camp 30 miles east of Tripoli.

Aster’s eyes filled with tears.

“They separated the men from the women,” she said quietly. “The guards would come drunk. At night they would take the women to sleep with them. Then another night, another would come. It happened to all of us.”

Hanna looked away.

“We were there 11 weeks,” said Aster. “It never stopped until we managed to contact someone who paid a bribe to get us out.”

When we called him, the director of Garabuli camp denied that rape occurred, saying that Africans might have Aids so his men wouldn’t take the risk.

Hanna and Aster live in the shadows of revolutionary Libya, prisoners in a country whose leaders say they fought for freedom. Terrified of Libyan men, they scarcely dare walk on the streets, relying on Hanna’s husband to bring them food. Hanna has left her two children in Eritrea with her mother. Aster’s three are with an aunt in Khartoum.

“I haven’t called them since I tried to go in the boat,” she said. “If I do she’ll just ask why I haven’t sent any money and I don’t want to explain.”

Europe is tough, I told them. You’d be illegal and that’s hard.

“It’s better than here,” said Aster. “Friends in Europe say you can get your rights and money.”

Why not return to Eritrea or Sudan, I suggested. Keep your head down, surely you can make a living somehow. They shook their heads.

I stood on the Tripoli coast and watched the north wind whipping up heavy seas across the Mediterranean. This year’s migration season is over, but come the spring, the people smugglers will be packing migrants into un-seaworthy craft and setting them on their way once more.

I asked Hanna and Aster what they would do now.

“We will look for money and try to reach Europe again,” they said.

Follow @lindseyhilsum on Twitter

Tweets by @lindseyhilsum

6 reader comments

  1. justine says:

    What the hell was the British government doing supporting Gadaffi’s opponents? It should have been trying to keep Gadaffi in power. We do not have enough jobs or affordable housing for our own native population + the immigrants that are already here. Don’t forget that the riots of 2011 were carried out by people overwhelmingly of immigrant stock. Last year at age 39 & childless, I had to have an abortion because my partner & I could not afford a child, & we were born & bred here & of British ancestry through & through.

  2. Christine Perkins says:

    The Maltese Government has complained that Malta is too small to help these desperate people. It has lobbied in the EU Parliament and tried to form a coalition of countries to stand with it against immigration from Africa. Amazing then that the same Government has passed into law this week a scheme to sell its citizenship to anyone for 650,000 Euros and 25,000 Euros each for any family members. The new ‘citizens’ do not have to live in Malta, invest there or even visit. They will be acquiring an EU passport and free to travel anywhere, even the USA under their visa waiver system. What double standards!

  3. sarah trayler says:

    I am delighted that you have highlighted the dreadful plight of the hippos and lions at the zoo in Libya. It was in the 1990s that animals were recognised by the European Parliament as sentient beings but it seems that the press and media have not been keeping up to date with this change. We hear a lot about the plight of people – but what about the animals? What is happening to the animals in the Philippines? The animals in Japan and the nuclear disaster? And what coverage is there of animal suffering in wars? Which agencies are helping them? Could this be a topic for 4thought? More coverage please, of animals in crisis and how to help them.

  4. Dave says:

    An extremely good piece of journalism, showing the real side of the story. If you are completing this type of journo then why not do the same in your own country and interview the real people who see what this country is turning into on a daily basis. We need to stop glamourising immigration and sort it out.

  5. Frida Yohannes says:

    Dear Lindsey,

    I so appreciate your story. It gives a voice to the unfortunate voiceless victims of a horrific human tragedy that is growing at an alarming rate right under our noses!
    I especially think that the stories such as the ones about Aster and Hanna’s situation and the suffering that accompanies it is one extra important to highlight. Due to stigmatization and culture, many women of the Horn will not find it so easy to speak of sexual assaults or rape, thus the issue becomes ‘invincible’.

    Also, you suggested “why not return to Eritrea or Sudan”? I am glad you asked this as this also shed’s light on yet another (unknown) obstacle for Eritreans in Libya-entrapment-they have no way of turning back once they make it to Libya; One one hand they have used all their funds to get there and since they have left Eritrea ‘illegally’ they cannot return as the consequences for fleeing are severe.
    So they are truly stuck between a ‘rock and a hard place’ where they have to choose between the devil they know or the devil they may find when trying to cross the sea.

  6. A Kidane says:

    Thank you for the informative article and clip.

Comments are closed.