Published on 13 Apr 2015

Is Ed Miliband’s fiscal responsibility promise just a Houdini lock?

Ed Miliband was on bullish form at Granada’s studios in Manchester launching Labour’s manifesto. You wouldn’t know it had been a tortuous business getting here, but ask anyone involved and it most certainly was.

He was performing the traditional political trick of nicking the other side’s political clothes – in this case the Tories’ Sunday best: their reputation for fiscal prudence. Ed Miliband said the Conservatives “are now the irresponsible party in British politics” – which rather begs the question of who used to have that mantle.

I asked Ed Miliband if the proudly proclaimed “fiscal responsibility lock” on page one of the manifesto was actually a bit like one of Houdini’s locks, something Ed Miliband knew exactly how to unpick.

 

Follow our election 2015 live blog for all the latest updates

The IFS says his rules are so deliberately vague that they could mean £18bn worth of additional cuts across the piece, or zero.

Ed Miliband insisted there would be cuts and there would not be zero cuts, but he still has a lot of wriggle room – he could be cutting £1bn or close to £20bn. The IFS says it is still unclear and he told us nothing really new on this today.

Follow @GaryGibbonBlog on Twitter

Tweets by @garygibbonblog

One reader comment

  1. oliver s says:

    I sincerely hope the electorate can remember 5 years ago. The Labour manifesto should have a Christmas tree with bank notes on it – pure fairytale. Their whole ethos is to spend money .

    If they combine in any form with the SNP , the The Queen may soon find herself selling the crown jewels as well as having to rent Balmoral for her Summer stay

Comments are closed.