19 Mar 2014

Budget 2014

This is not a major moment in the economic history of our country. There was no massive new direction set, more taps on the tiller.

Overall, over the five years, it’s fiscally neutral.

It’s £5.5bn of tax cuts funded by about the same in spending cuts. There are adjustments here and there and re-announcements of the 40p tax threshold and the fuel duty decisions.

19_savings_g_270x450The boasts for the pension reforms are great, but have a look at the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) estimates for the savings ratio (p 106 of the red book) and you wonder if a flashing red light on savings has kicked off the attention now given to the issue.

It doesn’t look very healthy even after the changes.

Treasury says actually the reforms will not improve savings rates, but increase freedom of choice in savings.

The Treasury says mean annuity market rates and changes to the state pension mean risks normally blocked by the Treasury can now be considered.

The IFS (Institute for Fiscal Studies) is sometimes seen as all-powerful and all-knowing. Its commentators get deity-like respect.

So it is fitting that it’s a graduate of their world, the pensions minister, Steve Webb, who dreamt up some of the most complex pensions measures the Chancellor so proudly announced today.

The OBR says that  the longer term impact of some of the savings measures are “subject to considerable uncertainty” (p 6, para 1.9) though it agrees in the first instance people drawing down more money earlier should pump up tax receipts.

George Osborne’s daughter Liberty, sitting in the gallery with her mother, joined in Tory MPs’ cheers as her father stood up. The usher nearby smiled.

Sitting in front of them was her grandfather, Lord Howell.

Liberty didn’t join in the cheering at the end, but she may have been puzzling over the details of the reform of  annuities.

Follow @GaryGibbonBlog on Twitter

Tweets by @garygibbonblog

2 reader comments

  1. Andrew Dundas says:

    What Osborne has done is eliminate the tax-free lump sum only for people with personal contribution pension funds. Folks with superannuation pensions will continue to get tax free lump sums.

    That means most superannuation pensioners (incl. Ministers) will pay their normal rate of tax, less 25% = 15% tax rate overall on the basic rate. Whereas, all others – almost all in the commercial sector – will pay 20% tax on every withdrawal. Why should this tax grab be widely characterised as some sort of benefit, when it’s a tax robbery?

  2. Philip Edwards says:


    I am PRAYING the tories put loony staring-eyes Grant Shapps in full charge of their PR campaigns, with Hancock, McVey and Newmark as presenters.

    That should see them into the wilderness for at least two generations.

    Only a crackpot London tory could think up that bingo and beer poster. It’s the shortest suicide note in history.

Comments are closed.