A school in Lancashire bars two Muslim schoolboys from classes because they will not shave off their beards. Should school uniform rules be respected – or is this a step too far?
The two boys were placed in isolation and taught separately from classmates after refusing to remove their facial hair at Mount Carmel Roman Catholic high school in Accrington, Lancashire.
The school’s head teacher said there were “standards to maintain”, insisting it was about the dress code, not religion. The two 14-year-old students are Muslims.
The school also prohibits false nails, fake tan, make-up, dyed hair and “inappropriate jewellery”.
It is not necessarily a religious obligation, but it is for some an essential expression of piety. Muslim Council of Britain
However, the Muslim Council of Britain told Channel 4 News it was about more than just a sartorial choice – and the boys’ stance should be respected.
“Following the example of Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) many Muslim males choose to keep a beard, which is considered to be an adornment of a man’s face,” a spokeswoman said.
@Channel4News Fair. I attended that school, and it’s the uniform policy. I was told to shave during my time there – no complaints, just tidy
— Dan McLaughlin (@MrDanMcLaughlin) October 4, 2013
“It is not necessarily a religious obligation, but it is for some an essential expression of piety. Any decision by Muslim pupils to manifest their religion by growing a beard should be respected by their school, just as Sikh men are rightly allowed to don turbans and grow beards.”
A relative of the students also told the local paper, the Lancashire Evening Telegraph, that it was “pure discrimination”.
But head teacher Xavier Bowers was sticking to his guns.
In a statement issued via Lancashire County Council, he said: “I am fully aware of the sensitive nature of this issue and have done my very best to be as understanding and reasonable as possible when dealing with situations of this nature.
“When necessary, we place pupils in our learning support centre who do not comply with our school policy regarding uniform and appearance.
@Channel4News Unfair. Why should men be expected to shave? It’s a personal decision whether or not to have a beard.
— Louise Z (@tabatha_tweedie) October 4, 2013
“Here at Mount Carmel RC High School, we believe that it’s important to maintain high standards in every aspect of school life, including appearance and uniform. Pupils and parents are reminded frequently of the rules on appearance, know that they apply to everyone and are regularly reminded of this.
“In my experience, families choose to send their children to this school because of our high standards and expectations.”
The beard row comes in the wake of similar controversy last month over female students in Birmingham wearing the niqab.
Mr Bowers had earlier told the Lancashire Evening Telegraph that he had spent time researching the issue and speaking to Muslim elders. The clean-shaven rule has apparently been in place for some time, although two boys were allowed to keep their beards on religious grounds as an “exception” last year as their GCSE exams approached and the school did not want to place them under “unfair pressure”.
He said that a number of other Asian boys were then spoken to and it was made clear they must return from the summer clean shaven.
It is understood talks are ongoing between the school and the families of the two boys to resolve the issue.
What do you think? Get in touch on Twitter @channel4news, Facebook or Google+
@Channel4News shaving a must for boys? Had to hoover school skirt 2 get it clean. Wdn’t let me in class otherwise.
— clare catford (@catfordc) October 4, 2013
@Channel4News It’s a little Orwellian. So long as natural hair or beard growth isn’t outrageously long, there shouldn’t be an issue.
— Nawaz (@NawazH37) October 4, 2013
@Channel4News School’s not the same as the real world. Just follow the rules. No one’s going to confiscate chewing gum in real life either
— Eric Rocket Boost (@TheBoostyBoy) October 4, 2013
@Channel4News I would imagine that’s a breach of human rights.
— Andrew Sunter (@SunterAndrew) October 4, 2013
@Channel4News Compromise: Trim beards to stay neat. I had to shave until 6th Form, where I was allowed to wear a beard for religious reasons
— Usama Hasan (@drusamahasan) October 4, 2013
— Tom Harrison (@theopenfire) October 4, 2013