Inside Nature's Giants

The Whale's Evolution

Features

Fin Whale

Monday 06 July 2009

Richard Dawkins

All our ancestors came from the sea and obviously went through great trouble to leave the sea and radically change to live on land.

Some of them, whales, sealions, penguins, turtles, went back into the sea which would seem to undo a lot of hard research and development and the need to reverse it.

Now as they went back to sea... their hind limbs gradually shrank in evolution. Not visible outside at all, but amazingly if you look inside, deep inside a whale you’ll find vestiges of hind limbs, little tiny remanants of bones which shows that their ancestors had real hind limbs that they actually used for walking.

I think it must be that something about living on land equips animals to do things which they could not have done had they not had this sort of long apprenticeship on land.

For example, they got warm blood, a slight misnomer, they got the ability to keep their temperature constant, which is extremely valuable for biochemical reasons.

Having got that then it became an advantage to do that even back in the water, and so going back into the water was a reasonable thing to do.

Whales are descended from land animals, their ancestors used to gallop over the country side, now they live in the sea. In a sense you could say they gallop through the sea, because the spinal movement of a whale as it swims through the sea is up and down, which is similar to what mammals do when they are galloping on land, unlike lizards, salamanders and indeed fish, from which they are all descended, where the spinal movement is side to side. At some point in the history of mammals they must have switched from a side to side spinal movement to an up-down spinal movement, and the whales even when they went back to the water retained the up down spinal movement.

I think it's something about being freed up from the constraints of gravity. A land animal has an immense weight to carry about and big animals like elephants have big tree trunks of limbs, they need them to carry them about.

Whales freed themselves up from that, it's almost like going into space or becoming a balloon floating through the air. They are no longer constrained by gravity, they are supported by the water. It then becomes a possibility to become more or less indefinitely large...

Comments

Your Comments

Post your comment

Please note: In order to post a comment you need to be registered and logged in to Channel 4:

Sign In Here or Register Here

Comments closed

Comments are closed at the present time

Your comments

Post your comment
By posting on this website you are agreeing to abide by our Comments Policy.
Mandatory Fields are marked with *
Your Comment (Maximum characters: 4000) *
You have

Comments

Thank you for your comment!

Your message will be reviewed and the best ones will be published below.

If you intended to make an official comment to Channel 4 please contact us.

Comments

  1. What excellent tv. Especially the part where the scientist diggs out of the whale a set of thigh bones [femurs] which PROVES that whales evolved from land walking animals millions of years ago! Go Richard - Go science!
    Posted by Neil on 21/07/2009 14:06:42
    Offensive? Unsuitable? Report this comment
  2. The Village In Cork Wanted To Keep The Skeleton To Put On Show In The Village. So When They Were Doing The Autopsy They Couldn Cut The Ribs To Get Into The Heart. I Was Quite Annoyed By That I Wanted To See The Whales Heart :(
    Posted by MrsPattz on 20/07/2009 22:14:20
    Offensive? Unsuitable? Report this comment
  3. as far as I know the village of kilbritain has the bones not sure what there doing with them
    Posted by nduggan on 07/07/2009 09:37:01
    Offensive? Unsuitable? Report this comment
  4. Hughsie - I believe a local school had asked for the skeleton so they could preserve and display it. That's why the lady anatomist was unable to get at the heart - she couldn't cut the ribs.
    Posted by Frugal Dougal on 06/07/2009 23:39:54
    Offensive? Unsuitable? Report this comment
  5. What did they do with the skeleton??
    Posted by hughesie162 on 06/07/2009 22:03:41
    Offensive? Unsuitable? Report this comment

Last on:

Monday 20 July

9PM, Channel 4

Advertisement

Skip Channel4 main Navigation
Explore Channel4
Food
Homes
Film
4Car
News
See All

Channel 4 © 2009. Channel 4 is not responsible for the content of external websites.