10 Aug 2015

The crowdfunding choir of Blaenavon

Home Affairs Correspondent

A Welsh male voice choir is crowdfunding a documentary about its efforts to secure the group’s survival.

Blaenavon Male Voice Choir, which was formed in 1910, has taken the unusual step in a bid to recruit younger members. Like many other male voice choirs in Wales, most of their choristers are in their 60s and 70s (five are octogenerians) and the move is being described by their musical director, Gareth Whitcombe, as a “pre-emptive strike” before it’s too late.

The male voice choral tradition in Wales, so emblematic of the country, is facing very real challenges. Last year Penarth Male Voice Choir, from South Wales, disbanded after singing in the town for more than 110 years. Reports of other choirs folding due to lack of numbers is largely anecdotal, but an ageing demographic among choristers has been a cause for concern for some time now.

Mining

Part of the problem stems from the fact that many of these choirs thrived in parallel with a mining industry which once proved the life-blood of their communities. The choirs’ erstwhile hotbeds of recruitment now appear a relic of the past.

Paradoxically, Welsh male voice choirs have gained huge popular acclaim in recent years. Only Boys Aloud, featuring teenagers from the South Wales valleys, were finalists in Britain’s Got Talent in 2012. Only Men Aloud shot to prominence in 2008 when they won the BBC competition Last Choir Standing.

The musical director behind both of these groups accepts that their success has had limited impact in terms of swelling the ranks of the older, more traditional choirs: “The male choirs themselves realise there is a problem and they need to recruit younger singers. But there is something that is stopping that happening,” says Tim Rhys-Evans.

Gulf

“I think the more the gulf between young people and the average age of the choirs widens my worry is that we’re never going to get it back. So we’ve all got a job to do.”

‘The culture and heritage is too good to lose. It’s a sound we can’t let go’ Musical director Gareth Whitcombe

Blaenavon Male Voice Choir, named best UK choir at the recent Cornwall International Male Voice Choral Festival, has transformed its social media profile in an effort to attract new fans. The collaboration with Cwmbran based Focus Shift Films – to crowdfund a documentary – remains a work in progress.

The production company is still trying to negotiate with a broadcaster to air the film, but they’ve raised more than £7000 in the process and have attracted celebratory support from the likes of actor Michael Sheen and musician Cerys Matthews.

Gareth Whitcombe is confident this latest initiative will provide the impetus they need: “The culture and heritage is too good to lose. It’s a sound we can’t let go”. Other choirs, no doubt, will be watching their progress with great interest.