Iran: the same mistakes, 31 years later
Updated on 11 February 2010
Thirty-one years on from the Islamic revolution in Iran, Massoumeh Torfeh looks at the similarities with the protests following the presidential elections last June.
Over 55 journalists are in jail in Iran – the highest on the list of the Committee for the Protection of Journalists.
In total, over 3000 people are said to be in prisons since the June's contested presidential elections. Many are young men and women, students, intellectuals, academics, and writers.
They have gone through show trials, made seemingly false confessions and are now behind bars for an average of eight years.
Two young men were executed last week and another has received his verdict today. Eight more are on the line. They are described as Mohareb (enemy of God) invariably accused of spying for the west – especially the UK and the US.
The introduction to their indictment refers directly to the Brookings Institute that had "written articles discussing soft revolution and popular uprising" as being the preferred American path in Iran.
How and on what basis these young men were connected to those articles was not made clear. Nevertheless they were killed.
It is 31 years since the Shah of Iran was ousted by making a similar set of mistakes. First he ignored the real grievances of the population, and then he continued with his belief that he was the "king of kings" and the sole representative of 2500 years of monarchy in Iran.
He alienated the masses by monopolising power and by consulting only a small circle of loyalists – just as the hard line clergy are doing today. And then once matters got out of hand, in desperation, he accused the West of having engineered the revolution through the BBC Persian broadcasts.
He called the BBC his "enemy number one" just as the Islamic Republic is accusing the BBC Persian TV of "soft power war". However, at least the Shah admitted towards the end that he had "heard the voice of the revolution".
Dictatorships always find an excuse for legitimizing their illegitimate rule. And then when they are hit back by the thrust of popular anger they seem to find it difficult to believe.
For over a century – 104 years to be precise, since the Constitutional Revolution of 1906 - people of Iran have been demanding freedom and justice. Yet rulers have deceived them time and again as we have seen in three major movements for democratization in Iran.
Authoritarian regimes were reinstated, every time more brutal and more organized than before. These appear to be fresh in the memory of the young generation.
YouTube and social networking sites favoured by young Iranians are these days full of references to those movements.
There are photos of the Constitutional Revolution showing men chained by the Qajar dynasty. Young artists are reviving poems that originated then yearning for freedom. The popular group Kiosk, until recently an underground group in Tehran, has just put out a joint production with the pop singer Mohsen Namjoo based on one the most loved songs of the constitutional era – Morgh e Sahar (the early morning bird).
The lyrics written by the constitutional era poet, Bahar, express a yearning for the end of the dark night, and the breaking of the dawn which would bring with it the breaking of the chains of prison when the early morning bird would sing the song of freedom for all.
Another song, Shame on You, based on a poem by Fereydoon Moshiri in 1953 expresses the pain of mothers whose children are in prison. It condemns the "gods of power" for being oblivious to what is going on around them.
The revival of these songs by the young carries a message for the authorities and a tacit warning.
The crisis in Iran is no longer over who should be the president. It is not even about the role of the Supreme leader, Ayatollah Khamenei, for that may be a foregone conclusion.
The crisis for the Shah was over the role of monarchy since in the collective psychology of the people the monarchy had gone further than its mandate. And this time the same question is posed over the future role of Islam in the political structure of Iran.
That may be the "voice of the revolution" that the supreme leader would have no choice but to hear sooner or later.
Massoumeh Torfeh is a research associate at SOAS specializing on the politics of Iran, Afghanistan and Central Asia. She is a former BBC journalist and UN spokesperson.
After 9/11 she worked in the office of President Karzai of Afghanistan as an information consultant. Massoumeh's PhD in political science is from LSE and on the process of democratisation in Iran.
