Skip Channel4 main Navigation
Explore Channel4
Food
Homes
Film
4Car
News
See All
[an error occurred while processing this directive]


RELATED STORIES

  • Dossier 'over-egged?'

  • Psychiatrist testifies

  • Campbell interview

  • Blair testifies

  • Blair's integrity

  • Hoon fights for job

  • Former spy testifies

  • Family trauma

  • Document bonanza

  • Surprise witness

  • MoD pressure

  • Susan Watts testifies

  • Gilligan grilled

  • Intelligence concerns




  • INTERNET LINKS

    Dr David Kelly's article
    Click here to read Dr David Kelly's article, written days before the Iraq war, in which he assessed the threat from Saddam.

    The Hutton Inquiry
    Daily transcripts and intelligence documents are posted here.

    Dr Kelly's testimony
    To the Foreign Affairs Select Committee, 15 July.

    The September dossier
    The September dossier on the threat from Iraq, from the Number 10 website.
    submit a url

    Channel 4 is not responsible for the content of third party sites.


    EMAIL

    Email Us
    Tell us your views
    Page Not Found - Channel 4

    Where's that page gone? Search us...

    This page cannot be found. Here are some options to help track down what you're looking for:

    • If you want to watch full-length programmes, browse all Channel 4, E4 and More4 programmes currently available to watch on our free 4oD service.
    • For more information on a particular show, try visiting our A-Z of programmes.
    • Alternatively, try typing your search term into our new improved Search.

    Advertisement

    Government accused of 'over-egging'
    Iraq intelligence



    Published: 03-Sept-2003
    By: Gary Gibbon



    Lord Hutton's inquiry has heard how members of the Defence Intelligence Staff had serious concerns that the Government was over-stating intelligence in its dossier on Iraq.


    For the first time, the Inquiry heard from the very people Dr Kelly had been describing in conversations with journalists when he talked about concerns in the intelligence community.



    The evidence painted a picture of intelligence assessments being rushed, concerns being over-ridden and the normal rigour over language being thrown out the window.



    The inquiry heard of a meeting held in the Ministry of Defence five days before the Iraq dossier was published.



    At the War office building in Whitehall, Dr Kelly joined a meeting of several experts from the Defence intelligence staff.



    It was a hastily convened meeting, called after the latest draft of the Government’s dossier had arrived on their desks. One man present at the meeting, a chemical warfare expert and weapons inspector, gave evidence to the inquiry today on an audio link - his identity has been withheld.



    He said everyone present questioned the new intelligence - now inserted in the latest draft of the dossier - which claimed that Iraq could deploy chemical or biological weapons in 45 minutes. He said it begged more questions than it answered.



    "The perception was that the dossier had been round the houses several times in order to find a form of words that would strengthen certain political objectives."



    Dr Brian Jones, who headed a team of weapons experts which

    formed part of the Ministry of Defence's intelligence service said: “We had problems about the source. What we were hearing was second hand information. The way in which the information was reported did not give us any real feel that the source knew anything much about the subject he was reporting on.



    "We even wondered, in discussing the issue, whether he might be trying to influence rather than inform. The information didn't differentiate between whether these were chemical weapons or whether they were biological weapons and that is an important matter.”



    “The absence of chemical weapons agent production worried us. We had not seen the weapons being produced. We had no evidence of any recent testing or field trials or things like that. So that all cast some doubts in our mind on that particular piece of intelligence.”


    C4 NEWS INFO
    The Channel 4 News site has been redesigned. This page is part of an archive of content from the previous website.
    Go to new homepage




    BREAKING HEADLINES
    channel4.com - Application Error Skip Channel4 main Navigation

       Application Error

    Apologies, but this page is temporarily unavailable.

    Our technical team are made aware of most faults almost immediately - and fix them as soon as possible. Please revisit the site at the next convenient opportunity, when we would hope and expect this problem to have been resolved.

    If you have returned to the site and are still having problems, please contact us here

    Best wishes

    Channel 4 webteam

    Channel 4


    channel 4

    Channel 4 © 2009. Channel 4 is not responsible for the content of external websites.