Skip Channel4 main Navigation
Explore Channel4
Food
Homes
Film
Comedy
News
See All

SCIENCE
Equinox 2
 
Riddle of the Leaning Tower
A Sense of Disaster
Deadly Code
Curse of the Phantom Limbs
Programme Outline
Aims
Curriculum Relevance
Activities
Teacher Notes
Background
Links
Do Parents Matter?
Curing the Incurable
Credits
TV Transmissions
Feedback
Print Version

Please use the menu on the left to navigate through this resource

Curse of the Phantom Limbs

Activities

 

Activity 1: Raising Awareness

(a) What do you know about how messages pass to and from the brain from different parts of the body?

(b) Discuss the following key questions:

  • How do unusual medical conditions throw light on the way complex mechanisms of the human body work?
  • How do new ideas challenge established theories?
  • How do people from widely different disciplines contribute to the development of understanding how the mind works?
  • How do simple experiments and equipment produce valuable scientific evidence?
  • What is the continuing value of research that may have been carried out many years ago?
  • What are the roles of humans and animals as participants in scientific research?

Activity 2: Phantom Seeing and Hearing

1. Use what you have learned from the programme about phantom limbs as the basis for suggesting answers to the following questions relating to one or other (or both) of the well-documented psychological phenomena, phantom sight and phantom hearing.

  • What groups of people might be prone to the phenomena?
  • What form might the phantom experiences take?
  • How might sufferers distinguish phantom experiences from real experiences?
  • What mechanisms might be the cause of the phenomena?

2. When you have recorded your answers, go online and log on to:

http://www.psy.uva.nl/resedu/PN/edu/CONSC/library/Melzack.htm

3. Scroll down the page until you find the section on ‘Phantom Seeing and Hearing’. Compare your own thoughts with the description given by Ronald Melzack.

4. Rate, on a scale of 1 to 5, how well you did in your transfer of ideas about phantom limbs to the associated phenomena of phantom seeing and/or phantom hearing.

Activity 3: The Silver Spring Monkeys — Did animal rights activists do science a favour?

Without the 11-year legal battle between scientists and animal rights activists over the Silver Spring monkeys, the radical idea of re-mapping of the brain might never have emerged.

Discuss some of the issues about the use of animals as the subject of scientific experimentation that arise from this particular case.

Activity 4: Create Your Own ‘Phantom Sensation’

1. Log on to http://www.newscientist.com/features/features_224322.html

2. Scroll down the article until you find ‘Try this at home folks’.

3. Try it and see what happens!