Skip Channel4 main Navigation
WHICH IS THE BEST METHOD FOR BRINGING UP BABY?
Not everyone agrees on the right way to raise a child. The heated discussions between the Bringing Up Baby mentors, as they discuss the merits and limitations of the three methods, are mirrored in real life, where experts and parents alike are still fighting out some age-old issues.
Who knew best?
So does the order of the 1950s routine provide the structure exhausted new parents are looking for? Does Dr Spock's advice, "trust yourself; you know more than you think you do", provide reassurance? And does the constant contact of the Continuum Concept produce a contented baby? Follow the links below to discover more about the methods, their pros and cons, and find out which modern-day childcare gurus have taken up the cause.
New rules
Some aspects of childcare theory have undoubtedly moved on in the decades since the books were first written. As our expert Harvey Marcovitch points out, "it's important to be aware that the three methodologies [used in the programmes] were modified somewhat in light of modern medical opinion." He has addressed 10 key questions directly relevant to issues raised in the Bringing Up Baby series. See Key Issues for All Parents.
 The 1950s: Dr Frederic Truby King’s Strict Routine Method
Routine, fresh air and show baby who's boss. |
 The 1960s: Dr Benjamin Spock's Baby and Childcare
Chuck out the rule book and shower babies with love. |
 The 1970s: Jean Liedloff’s Continuum Concept
Sling in your baby and join the tribe. |
