Skip Channel4 main Navigation

|Powered By Google


Think TV YOUR VIEWS
YOUR VIEWS
Have Your Say
On TV
A To Z
News
FAQ
Feedback
Help
Dispatches: Secrets of the Saudi State
'Sensationalist'? Let us know what you think


'Sensationalist'? Let us know what you think
Alan Hill
6th Mar 02
I found last nights programme Secrets of the Saudi State a very poor representation of the country. I have lived in Saudi Arabia and since being back in London for the past four years I have visited on about 15 seperate occasions. Firstly the people practising Christian services were breaking the law and would have been advised in advance of the strict rules and punishments in place. The man who worked in an illicit bar was also breaking the law. Again there are strict penalties. No one going to any country should go with a view to breaking the laws of their host. I agree that a lot of the punishment is barbaric but I believe that if you live in such a place you have to be vigilent at all times and practice a certain degree of caution. The bombings last year were in my view caused by the importers/distributers of alcohol not the end users where there is no rivalry. This is a very lucrative business and naturally there will be violence between rivals as there was during prohibition in the U.S. The woman who presented the programme made no effort to present a balanced view and just dug up what she could find. It is relatively easy to obtain a visa to visit the Kingdom but they are very strict about who they let in. There is a great deal of hypocrisy from the top down but that applies all over the Muslim world in todays modern society especially across the Gulf. I agree there need to be changes in Saudi Arabia and that unemployment, The role of the Royal Family and social reform need to be addressed. But sensationalising the judicial and internment issues will simply harden the governments position.
 
top