Monmouth: The Gothic House

Grand Designs Episode Information Monmouth: The Gothic House

Email this page

Contents:

Date Published:
05/06/2008
Monmouth: The Gothic House

Jo and Shaun Bennett are in love with the past, particularly Gothic architecture. Inspired by their love of all things medieval, the house that they dream of building is pure Addams family.

From the back, Jo & Shaun's five bedroomed gothic fantasy will be rather Rocky Horror, complete with arched stone windows and a tower.

Kevin And Owners: Monmouth: The Gothic House

But from the road the timber framed house, partly clad in stone, will sit with the local vernacular.

This project has the potential to be idiosyncratic and exciting but that depends on the budget - and particularly on Jo's talent.

Jo has designed the house and will be project managing it too, but she's having to squeeze in the build between a full time job and looking after her two young sons. With no architect and no project managing experience, she'll need all the support she can get.

And with such a small budget, realising this gothic fantasy is a tall order for even the most seasoned professional.

Budget And Build

Fireplace: Monmouth: The Gothic House

The Cost

Land cost: £150,000
Estimated Budget: £250,000
Final Budget: £450,000

Jo and Shaun's budget was always going to be unrealistic, especially considering the handcrafted, oversized Gothic features they wanted to put in.

The biggest expense was the £30,000 ornate hand carved staircase. One hundred and thirty pieces of oak for the faux beams cost £26,000 and the fireplace £6,000. Jo did however manage to save money in some places by using a prefab panelised structure for the timber frame of the house.

As plans changed and the build evolved, the costs escalated, which meant there was no contingency for any problems that occurred - waterproofing the roof, for example, or having to reorder wrongly-measured window profiles.

After re-mortgaging, Jo and Shaun eventually had to borrow money from their fathers to finish the build.

Scaffolding: Monmouth: The Gothic House

The Build

From the back, Jo and Shaun's five bedroomed house is a Gothic fantasy, complete with arched stone windows and a tower. But from the road the timber framed house, partly clad in stone, is in more of a traditional style, in keeping with the local area.

On the ground floor there is a large kitchen with an oak framed octagon in which to sit and eat.

Next to the kitchen, the modest hallway contains the centrepiece of the house, a carved oak Gothic staircase rising three floors, decorated with gargoyles and fancy carvings. An internal pointed window leads on to a miniature cloister, or sun room, to the South.

Leading off the hall is a large wood panelled living and dining room with a massive stone fireplace. Steps lead down through oak arches into the dining area. And the whole space opens to the first floor library and full height vaulted ceiling above, lit by a stained glass window.

Upstairs as well as the vaulted library there is a guest bedroom suite and the principal bathroom.

And at the end of the landing: the master bedroom, with dressing room, bathroom, balcony and, as in the kitchen, the same oak octagonal frame that forms the tower.

Upstairs on the top floor is a further guest room and the children's bedrooms and bathroom.

Your Comments

Post your comment

Please note: In order to post a comment you need to be registered and logged in to Channel 4:

Sign In Here or Register Here

Comments closed

Comments are closed at the present time

Your comments

Post your comment
By posting on this website you are agreeing to abide by our Comments Policy.
Mandatory Fields are marked with *
Your Comment (Maximum characters: 4000) *
You have

Comments

Thank you for your comment!

Your message will be reviewed and the best ones will be published below.

If you intended to make an official comment to Channel 4 please contact us.

Comments

  1. This is an awesome home...love it
    Posted by Ciaran on 08/11/2009 08:55:55
    Offensive? Unsuitable? Report this comment
  2. I enjoyed watching this episode thoroughly, this is now my new inspiration to go for what I believe in and what I think is right for me. This house is now my idol; I am hoping that one day I can have a house symmetrical to this one!
    Posted by April Izzard on 26/10/2009 20:21:24
    Offensive? Unsuitable? Report this comment
  3. As a student of project management I found Shaun's closing comments on having not having a project manager was ignorance of what their role really is. They are there to manage the project on their behalf and be the interface between them and the contractor's. The project manager would have assisted them in defining the scope of the project (which they didn't have, big mistake no.1) so that he can provide them a estimate on what it would most likely cost. Undefined scope = greater costs to the client. If it was over their budget, it given them option to appropriate more funds if they so desired, instead of overdrawing their limit later in the budget (mistake no. 2). Also the project manager would have allevaited major delays in the program such as the roof incident. Things always go wrong on projects, and it is how to manage the risks are managed quickly which makes a project successful. The project manager would have reduced the delay and get the project back on track. Greater delays in the project = greater cost to the client. Yes it would have cost them for the project manager's fee, but the cost wouldn't have blown out to double their original (and under estimated) budget. I felt that both of them we're trying to save face instead of considering the possibility that it could have done it better in hindsight. Only fools don't learn from their mistakes.
    Posted by Waku on 10/09/2009 16:01:38
    Offensive? Unsuitable? Report this comment
  4. I did feel sorry for these guys. They had a great initial concept, but then rather than paying an architect to come up with a play on Victorian Gothic that was within their budget, they did it themselves and got an attractive home but one that didn't really match up to the initial promise. And I think they should have ignored Kevin and gone for the bigger fireplace. It would have looked great.
    Posted by Mark J on 18/06/2009 15:09:09
    Offensive? Unsuitable? Report this comment
  5. thats the good thing about australia, there is heaps of room :D... but the thing i love about england is its historic arcitecture. but house like that wouldnt suit our austalian surroundings, and i reckoon they should of covered the whole thing in stone.
    Posted by josh on 02/03/2009 07:23:40
    Offensive? Unsuitable? Report this comment
  6. I really didn't like this grand design. Although the idea was good they made just too many mistakes on the way. For example they built it in the wrong place, they didn't have a realistic budget, they didn't build it out of proper solid materials; instead using cheap replica's (except for the staircase which was a complete success), and so on. Personally I would have found a quiet country location off the main road, maybe just a small lane for access and clad it all in proper stone. I would have used real solid timbers for the support of each level and probably increased the size by a few hundred square feet. But most of all I would have ensured it could be proper Victorian Gothic throughout, not just to the rear where it was unseen, that I find is the biggest problem of this house, the fact that they weren't allowed to build it the way they wanted, that I think is the main problem with this country, its too small and cramped.
    Posted by Simon on 16/01/2009 18:33:52
    Offensive? Unsuitable? Report this comment

Advertisement

More on 4Homes

4Homes Property Search

Over 300,000 properties to search, interactive maps, neighbourhood reports and more...

 

e.g. Notting Hill, SW3, Glasgow

Powered by: Nestoria

A-Z of Self Build Guides

Grand Designs Episode Archive

Grand Designs Extras

Advertisement


4Homes

Skip Channel4 main Navigation
Explore Channel4
Food
Homes
Film
4Car
News
See All

Channel 4 © 2009. Channel 4 is not responsible for the content of external websites.